Dir. Sam Liu
"Now Hulk know who to smash!"
Planet Hulk is the newest Marvel animated film that actually does something new. Instead of creating an entirely new story for these features, Marvel decided to model the film after one of the comic runs that was largely successful, that being Planet Hulk. Much like the first Ultimate Avengers feature. The movie is a lot like the comic, but more of a stripped down and clean experience.
The Avengers, or as we see in the film Tony Stark and Dr. Strange, due to copyright issues I imagine, capture and decide to send the Hulk to a remote island with no signs of life so his destructive properties will not do harm to anyone ever again. Unfortunately the planet Hulk lands on is a civilized one, that quickly captures him and places him in a gladiatorial setting where he's quested with three fights he must win in order to gain his freedom. It's an interesting concept, not in the plot, but in the relationships he builds with the other gladiators. The plot is really just a way for Hulk to smash stuff, and the comic even manages to wrangle in a fight between the Silver Surfer and the Hulk. Thanks to copyright issues again, the Silver Surfer never shows up. Instead we get the Thor reject, Beta Ray Bill. It's virtually the same fight, but nowhere near as epic or shocking.
My biggest complaint with the film is that it ends entirely too early and leaves important character bits out. The comic arc manages to keep going and eventually ends up being a tragic love story. What we currently get is a one minute scene towards the end that, out of nowhere, shows that Hulk and Caiera are in love. Any of the emotional weight, and the huge set-up for World War Hulk are gone. Also gone are many of the interesting side plots with Hulk gladiatorial teammates, especially Miek, and more importantly, any of the scenes where Hulk is being haunted by Bruce Banner, his former self, which gives the character a depth not found currently in the film.
The characters here are paper thin and are thinly veiled excuses for about eighty minutes worth of fight scenes. Which are done pretty well for the animated feature. They're on par for the course, but nothing truly remarkable or revolutionary. Without any of the weight, as I mentioned before, the film feels a little flat and a lot of the enjoyment could only be taken from the fight scenes. If you want more from your animated films, like I do, you'll likely want to stick with DC Universe films, especially Wonder Woman which had great characterizations and voice actors. Marvel animated features, with the exception of Doctor Strange, have really been struggling to get the formula down leading to a bunch of average films. And Planet Hulk is one of the lesser ones.
2 out of 5
